Chapter 2: The Sound of the Knife
The silence didn't happen all at once. It grew outward from Table 12 like grease spreading across a pool of water. First, the couple at Table 15 stopped their conversation mid-sentence, their forks hovering above their duck breast. Then the heavy-set man at the captain's table turned his head, his gold rimless glasses catching the chandelier light as he looked toward the window. Even the pianist seemed to feel the drop in pressure; his left hand hesitated on a low major chord, letting the resonance die out until only the high, thin notes remained.
Rose didn't move. Her thin hand, dotted with the brown liver spots of old age, remained frozen around the silver handle of her butter knife. She had been about to spread a small pat of butter across her sourdough roll. The knife stayed an inch above the bread, trembling so slightly that the silver blade caught a quick, erratic glint from the light above.
Her shoulders, which had been straight when she was looking at the snow, seemed to cave inward, collapsing toward her ribs like an old umbrella. The tiny, shy smile she had worn since six o'clock—a smile that Emma had thought looked like a birthday candle trying its best against a draft—disappeared completely, leaving her mouth small and blue and cold.
Emma stood six feet away, a tray of clean martini glasses balanced on her left forearm. She felt a heat rise from the heels of her shoes, up through her calves, settling behind her eyes until the entire room seemed to vibrate with a low, crimson hum. She had seen Victoria Greer-Vance before. Victoria’s father was Thomas Greer, one of the three principal stakeholders in the hospitality group that owned Maison Greer and four other steak houses along the river. She treated the restaurant like her personal dining room and the staff like an automated inventory system that occasionally needed to be kicked to function properly.
"Emma," Julian whispered, appearing beside her from the shadows of the host stand. His hand caught her elbow, his grip tight enough to bruise. "Don't. I'll handle it. Go back to the kitchen."
"Handle what, Julian?" Emma asked, her voice dropping into a register that made Julian look at her twice. It was too quiet. It was the sound her father used to make right before the barn door came off its hinges.
"Victoria wants her moved. Or gone," Julian muttered, his eyes darting toward Table 12, where Victoria was now looking at her manicured fingernails as if she had just finished ordering a side dish. "She’s Thomas Greer's daughter, Emma. If she makes a call, we’re both out on the street by eight o’clock. The old lady... she’s almost done anyway. I’ll just tell her there's a problem with the table billing or something. I'll give her a voucher for the cafe down the street."
"She’s seventy-nine today, Julian," Emma said. She didn't look at him. She was looking at Rose, who had finally put the butter knife down. The old woman hadn't looked at Victoria. She was looking at her own reflection in the dark glass of the window, her fingers slowly folding her linen napkin back into its original squares, her movements small and frantic and full of shame.
"I don't care if she's the Pope," Julian hissed. "The policy is the policy. The VIPs come first. Move out of the way."
Emma didn't move out of the way. She set the tray of martini glasses down on the server station with a sharp, heavy clack that made two of the stems ring. She adjusted her black apron, pulling the strings tight around her waist, and walked straight past Julian.
The floor seemed to grow longer as she crossed it. Every eye in the eastern wing was on her now. The rich people were waiting to see how the system worked. They were waiting for the garbage to be cleared so they could return to their truffles and their talk of municipal bonds.
Emma reached Table 12 first. She didn't stop at Rose’s table; she stood directly between Rose and Victoria, blocking the younger woman’s line of sight with her own black-vested torso.
"Good evening, Mrs. Greer-Vance," Emma said, her voice clear enough to carry to the middle of the room. She didn't curtsy. She didn't lean in. She stood perfectly vertical, her hands clasped behind her back. "Is there an issue with your reservation?"
Victoria looked up, her blue eyes turning into two small chips of ice. She didn't look at Emma’s face; she looked at the silver nametag pinned to her vest. "Emma," she said, pronouncing the name as if she were reading a label on a bottle of bleach. "I believe I spoke clearly enough for even the kitchen staff to understand. The atmosphere in this room is balanced for a certain... standard of clientele. That person behind you is disrupting it. She is an eyesore, and her presence is unacceptable. Remove her, or I will ensure that your employment here terminates before the valet brings my car around."
Richard Vance didn't look up from his phone. He simply reached out, took a sip of his Scotch, and turned a page on his digital screen. To him, the conversation was an administrative detail, like a clogged drain being discussed with a building superintendent.
Emma took a single step closer to the table. She could smell Victoria’s perfume—it was something heavy and jasmine-scented that cost four hundred dollars an ounce, but underneath it, Emma could smell the stale, sour scent of an old anger.
"The lady at Table 14 is a paying guest, Mrs. Greer-Vance," Emma said, her voice remaining perfectly even, though the pink slip in her apron pocket felt like a hot iron against her hip. "She is celebrating her seventy-ninth birthday. She has a legal right to sit by that window, and as long as I am the server on this floor, she will remain there until she chooses to leave."
May you like
The silence in the room didn't just deepen; it hardened.
Victoria’s mouth opened slightly, her perfect teeth gleaming under the golden light. She looked past Emma toward the front of the restaurant, her voice rising by three decibels. "Julian! Get the manager down here immediately. And call security. This girl has lost her mind."
