Chapter 2 - The Ghost of Catherine Mason
The kitchen of the rental house on Maple Lane felt smaller at 1:00 AM than it did during the day. The radiator beneath the window gave a metallic, wheezing rattle, puffing out intermittent waves of dry heat that smelled faintly of toasted dust. Outside, the snow was still falling, casting a pale, bluish sheen across the linoleum floor.
Thomas sat at the scarred oak table, the single overhead light casting sharp shadows across his face. In his palm rested the creased piece of paper Lily had given him.
Catherine Mason. 244 Orchard Lane, Columbus, Ohio. Safe person.
He unfolded it completely. The address was written in a clean, elegant hand—adult cursive, the kind taught in private schools decades ago—while the note underneath was scrawled in Lucy’s unsteady block letters.
Thomas pulled his laptop toward him, the screen illuminating his tired eyes in a harsh blue glow. He had spent the last two hours running background checks through public registries, property databases, and social media archives.
The name "Patricia Vance" came up first. A woman living in a modest split-level on the outskirts of Lakeside. No criminal record. Clean credit history. A registered nurse at a local county clinic. On paper, she was an upstanding citizen, a pillar of community stability. But public databases didn't record what happened behind locked doors when the snow fell and the world looked away. They didn't record the quiet terror in Lucy’s eyes or the bruised cheek half-hidden by blonde hair.
Then he searched Catherine Mason.
It took thirty minutes of cross-referencing old probate court filings, birth certificates, and archived university directories before a coherent picture emerged.
Catherine Mason was not a distant relative. She was Sarah Vance’s college roommate at Ohio State, a woman who had gone on to become a senior archivist at the Columbus Public Library. More importantly, she had been named godmother to Lucy and Lily when they were born eight years ago—before Sarah Vance passed away, before Patricia took legal custody, and before the twins disappeared into the quiet, suffocating nightmare of Aunt Patricia’s discipline.
Thomas’s phone vibrated against the table. It was a text message from a former colleague at his old financial firm, someone who still owed him a favor from an old audit.
Found the custody file, Tom. Sarah Vance died intestate four years ago. Patricia petitioned for emergency guardianship citing financial hardship. The court granted it because nobody contested it. There was a secondary record, though—a sealed memo from a family court caseworker noting a petition by a Catherine Mason for visitation rights, which was abruptly dropped two years ago after Mason moved out of state.
Thomas rubbed the bridge of his nose, feeling a dull ache forming behind his temples.
Two years ago. Right around the time Patricia had tightened the screws, isolating the girls, moving them from Columbus to Lakeside, cutting off every lifeline they had.
He looked down the dark hallway toward the living room. The sofa bed was quiet. Jason was fast asleep in his own room. The twins were resting, shielded for at least one night from the cold, the snow, and the woman who claimed to own them.
He knew what the responsible, legal, orderly man he used to be would do. He would call the Department of Job and Family Services in the morning. He would file an emergency report, hand the girls over to state custody or a temporary shelter, and let the gears of bureaucracy grind away for months while he returned to his tax forms and hardware store shifts.
That was what Thomas Grayson, corporate consultant, would have done.
But Thomas Grayson, father of Jason, widower of Elizabeth, looked at the small piece of paper with Catherine Mason’s address on it, and felt a cold, immovable certainty settle in his chest.
The system had failed Elizabeth when she was sick, burying her in medical debt and administrative delays. The system had failed Sarah Vance when she died, leaving her daughters to the mercy of a monster with a nursing degree.
May you like
He wasn't going to hand these little girls back to a system that treated human lives like paperwork.
He stood up, closed his laptop, and made a decision that would change the trajectory of their lives forever.
